• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Facebook Instagram Twitter Linkedin Youtube
  • Coach Nominations
  • Make A Payment
  • Call Us Today
Kozloff Stoudt Attorneys

Kozloff Stoudt Attorneys

Lawyers Serving Central and Southeastern PA

  • About Us
    • Firm History
    • Careers
    • Case Results
    • Legal Articles
  • Attorneys
    • George C. Balchunas
    • Daniel P. Becker
    • Kourtney E. Bernecker
    • Brian F. Boland
    • Brian J. Boland
    • Jeffrey R. Elliott
    • Allen S. Gehring Jr.
    • Andrew S. George
    • Michael C. Kochkodin
    • David M. Kozloff
    • Joan E. London
    • Rick Long
    • Colin J. Macfarlane
    • Michael M. Monsour
    • John E. Muir
    • Jestyn G. Payne
    • John W. Roland
    • Julia Adams
    • Barry W. Sawtelle
    • Peter F. Schuchman, Jr.
    • Charles N. Shurr, Jr.
    • Geoffrey M. Stoudt
    • J. William Widing, III
  • Practice Areas
    • Banking Law
    • Business Law
    • Business and Commercial Litigation
    • Debtor/Creditor Litigation
    • Employment & Discrimination Litigation
    • Estate Planning and Administration
    • Insurance Defense
    • Litigation
    • Municipal Law &
      School Law
    • Personal Injury
    • Real Estate
    • Sexual Harassment
  • Personal Injury
    • Auto Accidents
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Product Liability
  • Community
  • News
  • Contact
  • Make A Payment
  • Coach Nominations

PENNSYLVANIA COURT RULES THAT EMAILS ON TOWNSHIP SUPERVISORS’ PERSONAL COMPUTERS MAY BE PROPERLY SUBJECT OF RIGHT TO KNOW (OPEN RECORDS) REQUESTS

February 15, 2012 by 1seodev

As a result of a decision which may be a surprise to many Solicitors and Open Records Officers, elected officials’ (board and council members) personal computers are no longer off limits to an Open Records Request.  The prevailing thought had been, since those devices seemingly are not in possession or control of a Local Agency (school district, township, borough, authority, etc.)  any records kept there would not be “of the township”, as had been the Montgomery County Court’s impression in Mollick v. Township of Worcester.

The Commonwealth Court disagreed with the lower court’s position, at least in a case in which two or more elected officials are involved in the exchange.  The Court declared “regardless of whether the Supervisors herein utilize personal computers or personal email accounts, if two or more of the Supervisors (on a three person board) exchanged emails that document a transaction or activity of the township and were created, received or retained in connection with a transaction, business or activity of the township, the Supervisors may have been acting “as the Township”, and those email could be records “of the township”.  As such, any emails that meet the definition of “record” under the Open Records Act, even if stored on the Supervisors’ personal computers or in their personal email accounts, may be records of the township.

Of further concern is the Court’s focus on the exchange of emails being a “deliberation of the township business within the meaning of the Sunshine Act.”  By emphasizing such point, the Court allows for the possibility that aside from being an open records matter, the electronic exchange between two board members may be a violation of the Sunshine Act, which could result in individual criminal liability, including fines and sanctions in addition to those provided in the Open Records Act.

The Mollick case and others recently issued by our Commonwealth Court include other important rules and guidelines for local board and council members.  As such, we will be available to answer questions and offer further explanation upon your request.  For now, to paraphrase the “60 minutes rule”, we offer some general advice:  If you don’t want to see it on 60 Minutes (or the local newspaper, television or blog), don’t do it, say it or send it!

KOZLOFF STOUDT, Attorneys

Municipal Law Section

Category iconMunicipal Law Tag iconAttorneys Berks County

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Attorney Kourtney Bernecker Received her Bar Certificate
  • Julia Adams passes the PA Bar exam
  • What to Do If You’ve Been Injured in a Car Accident in Pennsylvania
  • Finding an Attorney for Your Business
  • Hope Gala

Categories

Archives

Footer

Wyomissing Office
2640 Westview Dr.
Wyomissing PA 19610

  • 610.370.6700
  • advice@kozloffstoudt.com

Legal Disclaimer

Information provided on this website should not be relied upon as legal advice or a substitute for legal advice. This information is being provided for general educational and reference purposes only. It is not intended to be used as a substitute for specific legal or other professional advice. You should not act upon the information without seeking professional counsel. Legal advice must be tailored to the specific facts and circumstances of each case.

Copyright © 2023 Kozloff Stoudt Professional Corporation | All Right Reserved | Design & Developed By CORE & DaBrian Marketing Group, LLC